ROSWELL ELDRIDGE
In almost every book written about Cavaliers, mention is made about the rich American businessman Roswell Eldridge who was disappointed that there were none of the longer nosed King Charles Spaniels of the older type around, and therefore placed a small advert in the 1926 Crufts schedule offering £25 for the best dog and best bitch nearest to this type to be exhibited at Crufts. This advert did in fact set the wheels in motion to revive the breed that we now know as the Cavalier. As very little has ever been written about Mr Eldridge in any of the Cavalier books we thought that this month we would tell you a little more about him. But firstly, here is a photocopy from the King Charles Spaniel section of the Cruft’s schedule for 1926 which contained the original advert placed by Roswell Eldridge. Just a very small advert at the bottom of a page that would start the ball rolling and bring about the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel as we know it today.

Twenty five pounds back in 1926 was quite a large sum of money. According to a retail price index calculator £25 in 1926 would be worth £1,030 in 2013. Twenty five pounds was awarded to both the best dog and the best bitch, plus two pounds for the second place of each sex and one pound for the third place. As this was to go on for five years the total amount of cash offered by today’s rate would be £11,530!
Roswell Eldridge was born in 1857 in Hempstead, Long Island, New York. His father was the town treasurer and Roswell’s first job was as an office boy working for the Udall Company, a large enterprise that was involved in property, transportation and steamship construction. He met his wife-to-be Louise Skidmore through his work as she was the daughter of the owner of the company. At first Louise’s family thought that Roswell was an unsuitable choice for her due to his more humble status and lack of both resources and social standing. However, his entrepreneurial drive soon proved himself to the Udall family and as he climbed the ladder of the company he took over the management of the property wings and also the steamship division and began running ferry boats to and from Manhattan. He then managed to take control of several other ferry companies and then sold them for a huge profit. He then moved to Wall Street as an investor for several banks and enterprises. With his own personal wealth vastly growing he married Louise in 1894. He started the Great Neck Bank in 1906 and between them Roswell and Louise Eldridge were accumulating a vast wealth. Around 1910 they built a huge sprawling columned mansion on Long Island which they named Udallia, and it was surrounded by a large estate of beautiful gardens leading down to a beach where he often moored his yacht Kehtoh staffed by a Japanese crew. Both Roswell and Louise were great philanthropists and donated vast sums of money to worthy causes.
The reckless world of rich businessmen in Manhattan and the sprawling mansions on Long Island in the 1920s were epitomised in Scott Fitzgerald’s novel ‘The Great Gatsby’, but rather than leading the high living playboy lifestyle described in that book, Roswell Eldridge led a more genteel way of life. In many ways he liked to live the life of a regal English gentleman and every year he would go stag and fox hunting in England with the West Somerset Hunt. He was a great dog lover and was a member of the American Westminster Kennel Club. When visiting Crufts he was disappointed not to see any of the longer nosed toy spaniels as depicted in many old paintings. Throughout the late Victorian era shorter faced oriental breeds such as the Japanese Chin, Pekinese and the Pug had become quite popular and the bloodlines from some of these breeds may have been introduced into the King Charles Spaniel to produce the flatter face. Longer faced spaniels still did turn up in litters but were not exhibited at dog shows and were probably just sold as pets. It was his determination to revive the older type toy spaniel that persuaded him to place the advert in the Crufts schedule and offer the monetary challenge to encourage breeders to try to resurrect the longer nosed toy spaniel.
As there were only just a few months between the publishing of the schedule and the actual show there were only four dogs entered in these classes in the first year. The winner of the dog class was Ferdie of Monham owned and bred by Mrs Treleaven with second place going to Lord Sukey owned by Miss Sparrow and bred by Mrs French. The winner of the bitch class was Fey owned by Mrs Higgs and bred by Miss Ellis with second place awarded to Flora Owned by Mrs Mallock and bred by Miss Anderson. Ferdie of Monham was the only dog that appeared to have a kennel affix so it is quite likely that they were originally sold as pets and not considered worthy of showing due to their longer faces.
Over the following four years the entries grew in these classes as more breeders took up the challenge to breed this type of toy spaniel, but sadly Roswell Eldridge never saw any of them as he died just one month before the 1927 show at the age of seventy.
So were these dogs the type that Mr Eldridge envisaged? We shall never know. Although he mentioned ‘the long face, no stop and flat skull not inclined to be domed’, when looking at old paintings there appears to be two types of toy spaniel that fitted that description. There were the very small dogs that were often called carpet spaniels or sleeve spaniels and also the slightly larger ones that appeared more sporting in type. The Blenheim spaniels on the Marlborough Estate threw up both types with the larger, more robust type being used as retrieving spaniels for small game and the smaller ones being used as ladies’ pets. Pictured below are two examples of the smaller ‘sleeve’ or ‘carpet’ spaniel.
 
Below are paintings that feature the slightly larger and more sporting type. As Roswell Eldridge was a keen huntsman it is more likely that these are nearer to the type of spaniel that he had in mind. He did in fact mention in his advert "as shown in the pictures of Charles II time" and the picture on the left shows Charles II as a child.
 
Miss Mostyn Walker was a breeder of short faced King Charles Spaniels and in 1926 she bred a dog called Lord Pindi to a bitch called Ann. In that litter there were two puppies that appeared to be throwbacks to the earlier longer nosed varieties. These were Ann’s Son (a blenheim) and Wizbang Timothy (a black and white). Miss Mostyn Walker also bred Papillons and there have been suggestions that there could have been Papillon breeding in Ann’s Son. These puppies did have the required longer noses and so she thought that they would be ideal specimens to enter in these special classes at Crufts. Ann’s Son was to take the first prize and Best of Breed for three years running in 1928, 1929 and 1930. Some years later in 1936 Ann’s Son won the £15 special prize for Best of Breed and also a £50 trophy which was a bust of Mr Charles Cruft. When Ann’s Son reached the age of nine he made his last appearance at Crufts and then was eventually retired from showing. Throughout his show career he remained unbeaten.
Pictured below is the only photo ever found of Ann’s Son. If you compare him to the two dogs in the above left painting of the young Charles II and his sisters you can see a distinct similarity.

the second day of Crufts in 1928 a band of enthusiasts gathered to discuss the formation of a club for these "Old type King Charles Spaniels." A committee was formed and a standard for the breed was drawn up. Ann’s Son was considered an ideal specimen and so he was placed upon a table for his attributes to be discussed for the proposed standard. They also had copies of some old paintings with the most prominent being ‘The Cavalier’s Pets’ by Sir Edwin Landseer. This picture is displayed below and was in fact featured in the Crufts catalogues for 1927 through to 1930. As you can see the head shape of the two dogs in this painting is not quite the same as Ann’s Son, even though they would both fit the standard. With the development of the breed over the years it seems that the modern Cavalier has more resemblance in the head to the dogs in the Landseer painting than to Ann’s Son.

There were some differences of opinions on how the breed standard should be interpreted and what exactly were the types of longer nosed toy spaniels that Roswell Eldridge first envisaged. By the late 40s / early 50s with the Cavalier breed firmly established it became clear that the modern Cavalier did look more like those in ‘The Cavalier’s Pets’. Mostyn Walker, the breeder of Ann’s Son, was not happy with the way the Cavalier had evolved and believed that they should be more like the very small ‘sleeve’ spaniels. In a letter to Amice Pitt around 1950 she mentioned that she had a very small dog that she believed would make an ideal stud dog and is more the ‘Henrietta d’Orleans’
type than Ann’s Son. In her words she said, "I look at him and think if only all Cavaliers were like him he should be untold gold to the breed and do away with the long backs, long legs and big dogs."
It was clear that she was more in favour of the small ‘Henrietta d’Orleans’ type than the ‘Cavalier’s Pets’ type. Below is a painting of Henrietta d’Orleans with her toy spaniel, and as you can see this dog could possibly fit in with the description that Roswell Eldridge mentioned but so too could the dogs in ‘The Cavalier’s Pets’ even though they are indeed quite different.

|